Truck Cartel Ruling!

· Automobile team
After years of legal disputes over the truck manufacturers' cartel, a German court has taken an important step by calculating how much buyers may have overpaid for certain vehicles.
Two recent judgments from the Regional Court of Munich I put the estimated additional costs between 1% and 5% of a truck's net purchase price, depending on the manufacturer and vehicle category. Although neither decision is final, the calculations offer transport companies a clearer reference point when pursuing compensation claims.
Different Compensation Rates for Different Trucks
The Munich court did not apply one percentage to every vehicle. Instead, it considered the manufacturer and truck category when estimating the additional amount buyers may have paid. For MAN vehicles, the estimated overcharge was 5% of the net price for heavy trucks and 1% for medium trucks. Daimler vehicles received different estimates: 3.7% for heavy trucks and 4.2% for medium models.
The cases involved two construction companies that had purchased trucks, including MAN and Daimler vehicles, between 1997 and 2009. Both judgments were dated 21 October 2026. However, the court did not accept every claim. One case involving a truck purchased in 1997 was dismissed because the court considered cartel-related financial damage insufficiently likely to have occurred.
How Experts Calculated the Losses
Determining whether a buyer overpaid is one of the most difficult parts of truck cartel compensation cases. Establishing that manufacturers coordinated their activities does not automatically prove how much extra a particular customer paid. To assess the financial impact, the Munich court relied mainly on reports prepared by two economists specialising in competition matters.
They used a method called regression analysis, which examines relationships between different factors to estimate the effect of the cartel on actual transaction prices. The economists had examined the issue in several related proceedings since 2019. Both sides challenged aspects of the expert reports and submitted their own analyses.
A New Reference Point for German Claims
The judgments are notable because German truck cartel litigation has involved many disputes over how to establish individual financial losses. The latest decisions provide concrete estimates for particular manufacturers and vehicle categories. However, they do not create a standard compensation formula that can automatically be used in every other case. Different purchases involve different vehicles, prices, manufacturers and supporting evidence.
One large group of claims involves Financialright Claims, which covers tens of thousands of truck purchases, leases and financing arrangements. In May 2026, Germany's Federal Court of Justice allowed such claims to be pursued in principle through claims-collection companies. It also noted that very large proceedings may need to be divided into smaller groups when their size makes a reliable examination difficult.
How the German Figures Compare
The Munich estimates are lower than several figures recorded in earlier cases elsewhere in Europe. However, the results should not be treated as a direct ranking because the legal proceedings involved different circumstances and evidence. In January 2026, a court in Milan set an 8% overcharge estimate for 141 medium and heavy trucks purchased during the cartel period. The case involved 14 Italian transport companies and the manufacturers Iveco, Scania, DAF and MAN.
A separate 4% estimate applied to six vehicles purchased after the cartel had formally ended. In France, a commercial court in Bordeaux ordered Daimler to pay more than €7,700 for each eligible vehicle in October 2025. The legal representatives of the carriers said their economic analysis indicated an overpayment of around 9%.
Spanish cases have produced a wider range of figures. A court in Cáceres calculated an overcharge of 16.35% in 2020. Other decisions included approximately 9% in Pontevedra, 20.7% in one specific Murcia case and 5% in Valencia.
The Background to the Truck Cartel
The compensation claims stem from findings concerning coordination among major truck manufacturers between 1997 and 2011. The manufacturers involved were MAN, Volvo/Renault, Daimler, Iveco, DAF and Scania. The European Commission issued decisions in 2016 and 2017 concerning their conduct. Five manufacturers received fines totalling approximately €2.93 billion in 2016, while Scania was sanctioned separately in 2017 with a fine of approximately €880 million.
The Munich judgments represent an important development because they put specific figures on estimated truck cartel losses for individual vehicle categories. For transport companies, the rulings provide a useful reference point, while confirming that calculating financial losses remains a case-by-case process.